The kids were starting a movie, and there was a preview on it for The Princess and the Frog, which we had the pleasure of seeing on Christmas Eve. As I pass the living room and start down the hallway on my way to the bathroom, I hear Hailey say "I thought she looked better when she was the frog because she wasn't black." Whoa whoa whoa...I turned around and came back down the hallway and started with "That isn't nice Hailey," then stood there at a loss for what else to say. I finally asked her why she liked Tiana better when she wasn't black, to which she responded that she looked more like a princess that way. WHAT??? Ok, at what point did my daughter become a racist? And where did it come from? I talked to her, explaining that black women can be princesses too, and that black people are our equals. Apparently she doesn't really think black people are pretty. OH MY GOSH.
I have no idea where this way of thinking has come from in my daughter. We don't even really talk about race as an issue in our home, because all people are equal in our minds. (Ok, wait, that may not be completely true - we don't talk about black people - we do occasionally make fun of Mexicans because my mother-in-law is one - but I am thinking that needs to stop before something bad comes of it.) But perhaps that is where we have gone wrong - maybe that has allowed her to form other thoughts and ideas based on what she is hearing somewhere else (although she says she hasn't heard anything about black people anywhere else.) I don't know. Jon says she inherited the genetics from my grandfather, a terminal racist from Missouri. This from the man whose grandmother told us once "Did you know that colored people are just like us?" with a tone of surprise in her voice. (Just for the record, Hailey wasn't around either of these people when they were ever talking about other races.) If it is genetic, we are in trouble.
So how do I impress upon my child that all people are equal, without making it seem like such a big deal that she ends up talking about it on the playground, which will inevitably make us all sound like racists?
Wow, this really made me laugh! (not at you, just at kids in general - they come up with the craziest opinions and ideas) I can imagine, were I in your position, I would be horrified.
ReplyDeleteDon't feel guilty!! This is not your fault. Kids tend to take things at face value without really thinking as deeply as adults do. Princesses in fairy tales are usually portrayed as white simply because they're typically stories that originate from Scandinavian countries. Germany is probably the most famous for it! So, as a result, most princessy shows or books have white princesses. Kids like things to stay the way they have always been. Mostly because they don't like change, no other reason. I'm not sure if that's what happened with Hailey, but perhaps.
Most likely, she's heard kids say slightly racist things on the playground. (which they probably picked up from they're parents, sadly) Maybe she just needs more talk about race, but that's a tough one.
I have no children yet. I'm really no help here! But it seems like she could use a conversation or two to steer here in the right direction. My advise would be to just keep your ears open for her to say something that could possibly sway the conversation in that direction. That way your not sitting her down for a serious discussion. (that might feel like she's in trouble and is getting a lecture) Keep it casual. It may take time.
Good luck! Life is funny, no?
Actually, the more I think about it, the fact that you simply said "That's not nice" and "princesses can be black", probably helped a lot more than you think!! Kids really listen to their parents opinions. Even if they don't seem like they do.
ReplyDelete